Scottish local government strike ballot narrowly lost
By a UNISON member. Posted 20th August 2013
UNISON members in Scottish local government have voted by a very narrow margin not to take strike action on pay. The ballot of 75,000 members saw 49.8% vote in favour of three days of strike action with 50.2% voting against. Members had voted by a margin of 3:2 in an earlier consultative ballot to reject the 1% pay offer, which is of course a pay cut in real terms.
The GMB trade union accepted the offer months ago. UNITE members rejected the offer at the same time as UNISON members however their trade union has not as yet run an official strike ballot.
The result is a setback in the fight against the ConDems attacks on working class peoples’ living standards. This particular attack is of course being implemented on behalf of the ConDems by the Labour and SNP dominated Scottish local councils employers group.
Some of the explanations for the result include the possibility that some members understandably remain to be convinced that individual trade unions in isolation can defeat the austerity measures of Westminster and Holyrood, the idea put about that against the backdrop of 35,000 lost jobs in local government in Scotland since 2009 they are fortunate to have a permanent job, others may have accepted the council employers argument that they don’t have the money to make higher pay awards and some low paid workers may have been persuaded that the introduction of a “Scottish local government living wage” of £7.50 per hour was a decent concession by the employers. It is also likely that the delay in getting to an official strike ballot may have created a feeling amongst some members that it was too late to fight on an offer that was due from April 2013 (the offer was tabled December 2012 and the official strike ballot did not begin until July this year). The fact that the ballot was conducted over the summer holiday period was also obstacle to mobilising members.
However, it is important to point out that UNISON proposed an initial three day strike programme, rather than the usual “one day and review” approach adopted in previous national ballots, and that nearly half of members voted to support that programme. Some UNISON branches argued acceptance of the offer from day one but the closeness of the ballot shows that it was correct to adopt the Glasgow branch’s position of testing the mood of the members by campaigning for a Yes vote based on the principled position of not recommending further cuts in their living standards.
This setback in the battle against austerity may be shortlived. And can be overcome by a movement over other issues, including a certain below inflation offer from the employers for next year.
It is the job of left branches and activists to build the mood and morale of members for the struggles ahead, to continue to fight for effective industrial action including the building of a 24-hour general strike to defeat the cuts.
